BLOG FOR ENTREPRENEURS
The Newest Player in Early Stage Financing Rounds: the SAFE
Companies looking to raise early stage funds should seriously consider the Simple Agreement for Future Equity, or SAFE.
Companies looking to raise early stage funds should seriously consider the Simple Agreement for Future Equity, or SAFE. First announced by Y Combinator in late 2013, the SAFE is a simpler, faster tool for raising money than the convertible note structure which has been predominant in early round financing since 2010. Investors can fund through a SAFE, and in most cases there is no further action required until the SAFE automatically converts into true equity at the time the company closes its first round of equity financing. Crucially, the company can avoid setting a valuation when the SAFE investment is made (like with convertible debt). Typically, the company and its investors will only need to negotiate an appropriate valuation cap before closing a SAFE investment. Unlike convertible note financings, which require negotiation of interest rates and maturity dates (and potentially re-negotiations if the debt remains outstanding at the maturity date), and which often require the company to issue warrants and/or encumber its assets with a security interest, a SAFE should require less negotiation with investors. SAFE financings are done through a single agreement. They can be negotiated as larger multi-investor rounds, or as one-off agreements.
Given that the initial wave of SAFEs were closed in 2014, primarily on the West Coast, there has been some natural reluctance by investors to adopt this approach over the more established convertible debt financing or even a pre-seed/seed equity round. Companies can seek to entice any such cautious investors through conversion discounts (like with convertible debt), MFN clauses or other protections. As a general rule, SAFEs are adaptable instruments that can be customized to fit the company and its investors. In a similar vein, although SAFEs were designed primarily for Delaware corporations, an LLC or other entity (whether or not formed Delaware) can raise money through a SAFE.
Less Members of Board of Directors = Bigger Results
Must read article from the National Law Review on the benefit of having a small number of members of your Board of Directors: "Smaller boards tend to be “decisive, cohesive, and hands-on,”
Forming A Startup
Forming a startup can be a difficult decision that should not be made alone. It's vitally important that you consult with both a business attorney and accountant before making such decisions. I include accountants as part of this decision making process because tax rules are a primary driver to what will be the most advantageous formation solution for your business.
With that in mind, the following sets forth the main differences among C corporations, S corporations, and limited liability companies:
C Corporations
While corporations provide limitation of liability for their shareholders, they are subject to double taxation (i.e. the corporation is taxed on profits and then the shareholders are taxed on amounts distributed to them). On the flip side, if you are seeking financing from venture capitalists, you may very well need to form as a C-corporation as institutional VCs prefer investing in C-corporations.
Limited Liability Companies
LLCs provide limitation of liability like a C-corporation. Many LLCs are taxed as a partnership and are considered disregarded entities (i.e. the LLC is not taxed on profits, but the shareholders are taxed on the distributions they received from the LLC). LLCs may elect to be taxed as a partnership, as a C corporation, or as an S corporation. When people refer to the tax treatment of LLCs, they usually mean an LLC that has elected to be taxed as a partnership. Taxed as a partnership, the LLC is a “pass-through entity” that is not taxed.
S-Corporations
An S-coroporation provides limitation of liability like a C-corporation. An S-corporation is an election filed with the IRS, not a form of entity. LLCs, as well as corporations can be taxed as an S-corporation. Like an LLC taxed as a partnership, an S corporation is a pass though entity with a single layer of tax. A main difference between S-corporation taxation and partnership taxation is that the distributions received by LLC members who assist in running the business are subject to self-employment tax. With S-corporations, shareholders can reduce employment taxes by taking part of their income in salary (and paying employment taxes) and taking the rest of their income as a distribution.
This is just a brief example of the differences. Other rules not mentioned here may apply to you and your business. Feel free to contact us for a free consultation.
TechCrunch Must Read
Great article about how crucial it is for entrepreneurs to build the right team for their startup beyond the founders.