BLOG FOR ENTREPRENEURS
The Coming IP Fights That Could Reshape AI
Reuters reports that OpenAI, Microsoft, The New York Times and a group of authors are asking a federal court to address whether copyrighted books and news articles can be used to train AI models under the doctrine of fair use.
But that's only one side of a much larger intellectual-property question.
The next major battle over artificial intelligence may not be about what AI can do. It may be about what it can use, and who owns what it creates.
But that's only one side of a much larger intellectual-property question.
On the input side, courts are beginning to grapple with whether AI companies can train their models on copyrighted material without permission.
On the output side, an equally important question is developing: Can inventions, content and other valuable assets created with AI actually receive intellectual-property protection?
Current U.S. law still places considerable importance on human involvement. The USPTO maintains that only natural persons can be inventors, although AI-assisted inventions can qualify for patent protection. The Copyright Office similarly distinguishes between AI used as a tool by a human creator and material generated by AI without sufficient human authorship.
That creates a fascinating tension.
Companies are investing enormous amounts of money in AI partly because of what it can create. Yet the more independently AI creates, the more complicated the question may become of who owns, or can protect, the resulting asset.
For businesses, this is much bigger than copyright litigation. It touches patents, copyrights, licensing, data rights, contracts and ultimately the value of AI-generated intellectual property.
The first cases are beginning to work their way through the courts and agencies.
The larger fight over what AI can use, what AI can create, and who owns the value on either side may just be beginning.
-Matthew Murphy
Don’t Let “It’s Our Policy” End the Negotiation
…contracting policies serve an important purpose. They create consistency, establish negotiating parameters and streamline approvals. But a contracting policy shouldn't become a substitute for negotiation. “It's our policy” shouldn't mean “take it or leave it”, particularly when a reasonable alternative addresses the underlying concern.
“It’s our policy.”
I hear this constantly in contract negotiations. We can't change the indemnity. We can't change the liability cap. We can't change the payment terms. It's our policy.
Here's the problem: it's very often not true.
There is a big difference between “this is our standard position” and “we can't change it.”
Don't believe me? Spend some time looking at publicly filed agreements on the SEC’s EDGAR website. Large, publicly traded companies agree to terms that depart from their standard positions and policies all the time because different transactions involve different economics, leverage and risk.
Don't get me wrong, contracting policies serve an important purpose. They create consistency, establish negotiating parameters and streamline approvals. But a contracting policy shouldn't become a substitute for negotiation. “It's our policy” shouldn't mean “take it or leave it”, particularly when a reasonable alternative addresses the underlying concern
If a provision doesn't fit the deal or allocates risk disproportionately, push back. Explain why. Give them a reasonable alternative.
I've lost track of how many times “we can't change that” eventually became “let me see what I can do.”
Policy matters. So does reasonableness.
Trust Stacking and QSBS: Is the Window Starting to Close?
The IRS is looking closely at arrangements designed principally to multiply exclusions without much substance behind separate trusts. Treasury officials have specifically raised concerns about multiple trusts with overlapping beneficiaries.
How Much Longer Can Founders and Investors Use Trust Stacking?
Earlier this summer, the Treasury Department cast a spotlight on trust stacking. As reported by The Wall Street Journal, Kenneth Kies, Treasury’s top tax-policy official, warned: “Let me just warn you, we don’t like stacking, OK?” Founders and investors have taken notice.
Since the 1990s, founders and other investors in qualifying startups have been able to shield millions in capital gains on the sale of qualified small business stock (QSBS) under Section 1202. Last year, Congress expanded those benefits under the OBBBA. For qualifying stock acquired after July 4, 2025, investors can potentially exclude up to $15 million of capital gains (or 10x their basis), subject to the applicable holding-period requirements.
Savvy investors have long multiplied those savings through “trust stacking.” For example, a founder could establish separate non-grantor trusts for each of his three children and transfer 25% of his qualifying shares to each. The founder and each trust could potentially qualify for its own $15 million exclusion — $60 million in total.
One interesting feature is that the trusts can generally tack onto the founder’s holding period. A trust receiving QSBS by gift does not necessarily start the clock all over again.
I am a corporate lawyer, not a tax lawyer. But I have represented numerous founders and investors who have taken advantage of QSBS through the sale of their companies. We have also worked with clients who exited one QSBS investment and rolled the proceeds into another under Section 1045. These rules can have an enormous impact on the economics of an exit.
Not surprisingly, a cottage industry has developed around maximizing these benefits, and some strategies are more aggressive than others.
The IRS is looking closely at arrangements designed principally to multiply exclusions without much substance behind separate trusts. Treasury officials have specifically raised concerns about multiple trusts with overlapping beneficiaries.
Timing matters too. If a founder waits until the sale is essentially a done deal before transferring shares to newly created trusts, the IRS may argue that he simply assigned income from an already-fixed sale. As the WSJ notes, advisers are particularly wary once there is a binding commitment to sell.
That does not mean legitimate trust stacking is going away. Separate non-grantor trusts for genuinely different beneficiaries have long been part of estate and QSBS planning. But Treasury has signaled that additional guidance is coming.
For founders and investors holding QSBS, the broader lesson is familiar: planning for an eventual exit should begin well before the exit. If a trust or other wealth-transfer strategy makes sense, establishing it before the shares skyrocket in value — and certainly before the sale process is effectively committed — can make an enormous difference.
Back-Door Unlimited Liability: The Indemnity Trap in Commercial Contracts
There are risks that may appropriately sit outside a general liability cap, such as IP infringement, gross negligence or willful misconduct, for example, and others that may warrant a separate, higher cap.
But that should be intentional, understood and proportionate to the deal, not the unintended result of an overly broad indemnity.
You negotiated a liability cap that you think protects your business and its value.
Then you read the indemnity… Think again.
There’s a back door hiding in plain sight.
Indemnities are intended to allocate specific risks, often involving third-party claims. But just as often, I see overly broad indemnities covering all losses arising from any breach of the agreement, negligence, or - worse yet - simply as a result of providing the Services.
Then you go back to your hard-negotiated limitation of liability provision and find:
“The foregoing limitation does not apply to Service Provider’s indemnification obligations.”
That’s what I call back-door unlimited liability.
And if you missed it, your carefully negotiated liability cap would be effectively useless.
There are risks that may appropriately sit outside a general liability cap, such as IP infringement, gross negligence or willful misconduct, for example, and others that may warrant a separate, higher cap.
But that should be intentional, understood and proportionate to the deal, not the unintended result of an overly broad indemnity.
So when you negotiate a liability cap, don’t stop there.
Because that’s where back-door unlimited liability is hiding.
The Threat is Coming From Inside the Business
More revenue brings new hires, and new hires can bring... well, sometimes it depends. A recent employee embezzlement case sheds light on the constant focus that CEOs and Founders need to maintain as the enterprise brings in new talent and scales up.
In my work with SMBs, it is genuinely exciting to watch our clients cross new growth thresholds. More revenue brings new hires, and new hires can bring... well, sometimes it depends. A recent employee embezzlement case sheds light on the constant focus that CEOs and Founders need to maintain as the enterprise brings in new talent and scales up.
Pamela Aguilar, 65, the former CFO of a Danbury, Connecticut software company reportedly identified as MaxQ Technologies, pleaded guilty in June to wire fraud after admitting that she stole $739,466.44 from her employer between approximately 2018 and 2025. She used ACH and wire transfers, checks, cash withdrawals, PayPal and credit card payments to divert company money for her own benefit.
What makes the case particularly interesting is how she concealed it. According to the U.S. Attorney’s Office, Aguilar provided the company’s CEO with false weekly cash reports and false monthly financial statements. It wasn't like the CEO had vacated his duty of oversight; rather, the reports themselves were a key part of the fraud. The company's reported annual revenues were in the low single digit millions, meaning that the amount that Aguilar was siphoning off, roughly $9,000/month, may have accounted for 5-8% of monthly revenue. So, just enough to allow her to boost her lifestyle, but also low enough to evade the CEO's notice for several years.
It is a classic controls issue - the executive with access to the company’s money was also providing management with the information it relied upon to determine what was happening to that money. For owners of growing businesses, the lesson is not that you should distrust your CFO. Rather, the question is whether trust is being independently verified.
We constantly work with Founders and Management who get a bad whiff coming from somewhere inside the organization, but may not be confident of how or where to start investigating. In Aguilar's case, she began the scheme very quickly after beginning the job, which is often what we see. It is always a good idea to enlist outside help to poke and prod until you can uncover whether there is a problem. The longer you wait, the worse it gets.
Thibaut Acquires Murphy Bova Client Rosemary Hallgarten Inc.
Thibaut, the 138-year-old fabric, wallpaper and furniture company, has acquired textile brand Rosemary Hallgarten.